Evidence
How the survey decides
The decision is evidence, not preference. A
condition survey
establishes the facts that matter: is the surface underneath dry, is the
existing covering still stuck down, what state are the upstands and
details in,
and what can the structure take. Overlaying a wet roof traps moisture
and buys a few years at the cost of the deck; stripping a dry one
wastes money and fills a skip for nothing. The survey exists so
neither happens to you. Before you commission anything, the
questions worth
putting to any roofer are worth having to hand.
Systems
Which overlay: liquid first, felt by exception
Liquid is the route we recommend, and the reasoning is structural
rather than a matter of taste. Overlaying in felt asks the building to
hold a second sheet covering on top of the first, and every sheet
brings joints with it, which is where flat roofs give way. Cold-applied
liquid cures as a single piece with nothing to open, follows the
details rather than being cut around them, needs no flame near
anything combustible, and weighs a fraction of what it replaces.
That does not make liquid right everywhere, and the conditions on this
page do not move: the existing roof still has to test dry through its
layers, hold firmly to what it sits on and take preparation without
breaking up. Where a roof genuinely suits a fresh built-up system
instead, a felt overlay is specified and the report says why, whether
that is the detail count, what is already up there or the weather the
job has to be finished in. The system named in your quote is the one
the roof argued for. Where the roof you are overlaying is itself felt,
the tests it has to pass are
set out substrate by
substrate.
Money
The cost logic, without invented numbers
We price each viable option in writing after the survey, and the logic
is consistent: repair costs least; an overlay saves the strip-off,
disposal and much of the disruption; strip and renew costs most and
delivers a completely new covering. Where options are genuinely close,
we say so and explain the trade instead of steering you to the dearest
one.