Flat Roof Refurbishment: Which Option Your Roof Needs
Flat roofs are our trade across South London, which is why this page argues for three
options instead of the one that pays best: repair it locally, lay a
new membrane straight over the old, or strip it back and renew it. Which one your roof gets is settled by an inspection, priced
afterwards rather than guessed at, and set down with the reasoning
attached.
The short answer:
Three routes exist for a worn flat roof: a localised repair, a new membrane laid over the old, or a strip back to the deck. An inspection settles which, because the choice depends on how much sound covering and dry boarding remain.
Straight talk
The three options, honestly compared
Localised repair
Right when faults are isolated and the covering is otherwise
sound: a split at a lap (an overlapping seam), a cracked upstand
(a turned-up edge at a wall), a failed detail. The
cheapest option, and often all a roof needs.
Right when the covering is worn out but the deck and insulation
beneath are dry and well bonded. Our recommendation is
liquid-applied waterproofing,
HYDRONYLON worked over an inspected covering; a
felt overlay is the
exception, and the quotation gives the reason whenever it is one. Either
way the strip-off is avoided. An overlay is the full system over an
existing base rather than a reduced one: what changes is not the
specification but what stays underneath it, and with that the
age and falls the roof keeps.
Strip and renew
Right when moisture has got beneath the membrane, the deck is
damaged, or failure is widespread. Costs most, but resets the
roof completely instead of covering a problem over.
Whether you call it refurbishment or restoration, the decision is
evidence, not preference. An inspection
establishes the facts that matter: is the surface underneath dry, is the
existing covering still stuck down, what state are the upstands and
details in,
and what can the structure take. Overlaying a wet roof traps moisture
and buys a few years at the cost of the deck; stripping a dry one
wastes money and fills a skip for nothing. The inspection exists so
neither happens to you, and where the findings are wanted as a
document for somebody else, a
written condition survey
is the paid option. Before you commission anything, the
questions worth
putting to any roofer are worth having to hand.
On a large commercial roof where the inspection leaves all three
options open, the assessment we carry out on large
roofs weighs each one against measured evidence.
Converting to a warm roof costs least once the old covering is off,
though an insulated overlay can make the change without stripping
anything on a dry deck whose upstands are tall enough for the extra
depth, and what that
warm roof conversion
involves on site has its own page.
Systems
Which overlay: liquid first, felt by exception
Liquid is the route we recommend, and the reasoning is structural
rather than a matter of taste. Overlaying in felt asks the building to
hold a second sheet covering on top of the first, and every sheet
brings joints with it, which is where flat roofs give way. Cold-applied
liquid cures as a single piece with nothing to open, follows the
details rather than being cut around them, needs no flame near
anything combustible, and weighs a fraction of what it replaces.
That does not make liquid right everywhere, and the conditions on this
page do not move: the existing roof still has to test dry through its
layers, hold firmly to what it sits on and take preparation without
breaking up. Where a roof genuinely suits a fresh built-up system
instead, a felt overlay is specified and the quotation says why, whether
that is the detail count, what is already up there or the weather the
job has to be finished in. The system named in your quotation is the one
the roof argued for. Where the roof you are overlaying is itself felt,
the tests it has to pass are
set out for existing felt
roofs.
Before The existing felt roof.After The same roof under liquid-applied waterproofing.
Money
The cost logic, without invented numbers
We price each viable option in writing after inspecting the roof, and the logic
is consistent: repair costs least; an overlay saves the strip-off,
disposal and much of the disruption; strip and renew costs most and
delivers a completely new covering. Where options are genuinely close,
we say so and explain the trade instead of steering you to the dearest
one.
The decision
The roofs we refurbish
Which of these you have is largely an accident of where the building
stands. Interwar suburbia out towards
Petts Wood and Orpington or
New Malden and Tolworth is full of felted
garage roofs; the mansion blocks and converted wharves nearer town, in
Rotherhithe and Bermondsey for instance,
throw up asphalt and concealed parapet work instead.
The three options above apply to whatever is already up there, but
what is already up there changes the detail of the answer. These
pages take each common covering in turn: how it fails, what an inspection
checks on it, and where its own limits sit.
Mastic asphalt: the
jointless bitumen surface under a great many London parapets, and
the material most often worth renewing in place.
Single ply, PVC and TPO:
repair and overlay of existing membranes, with the suitability
question answered honestly.
Metal, flat and low pitch:
profiled sheet and standing seam on industrial units, where cut edge
corrosion is the classic fault.
One building type reaches these three options from somewhere else
entirely. The roof over a garage is usually the oldest on the property
and frequently the only one nobody has ever renewed, so it arrives
without the insulation finding that settles most of these arguments and
decides on the boards
alone.
Lead, concrete and glass reinforced polyester all turn up on London
roofs too, and none of them has a page here yet. For each of them the
work is repair, and an overlay wherever the substrate allows one, once
an inspection has identified the surface and an adhesion test carried
out up there has had its say. Concrete and screed are among the surfaces our
liquid system's
assessment names; lead and glass reinforced polyester are not, so
what any guarantee then covers is written into the quotation. Ask
about yours and you will get the same answer in writing.
Whichever of the three a roof ends up having, we offer a repeating
maintenance visit on it once the work is signed off, quoted for that roof and
chargeable from the first one. What sits inside that fee, and what is
priced on its own, is set out under
aftercare on the planned
maintenance page.
Parapet gutters, copings and the flat section by the roof hatch in white liquid-applied waterproofing, the hips and ridge in the same membrane.
Questions
Frequently asked questions
Does a tired flat roof always need replacing?
No. If the deck, the structural boards a flat roof is built on, and the insulation underneath are dry, a localised repair or a full overlay is often the better answer, at a fraction of the cost and disruption of replacement. Replacement is the right call when moisture has spread beneath the membrane or the covering has failed across its whole area.
What is a roof overlay?
An overlay is a new waterproof layer installed over the prepared existing covering. One thing it does not dodge: renewing a covering right across a roof can bring its thermal performance into scope in the same way a strip and renew does, so the insulation question belongs in the same conversation. We recommend cold-applied liquid waterproofing, because it hardens into a single piece and asks almost nothing extra of the structure holding it. Torch-on felt over the top is the exception rather than the norm, taken where a roof suits it. Where the base underneath is dry and sound, either saves the cost, disruption and waste of tearing that base off.
When does a roof need stripping back and rebuilding?
When the inspection finds wet insulation or a damaged deck, when previous coverings have been layered too many times, or when the roof has failed widely rather than locally. At that point an overlay would trap the problem, so the honest option is to strip back and rebuild the covering properly.
How do you decide between repair, overlay and replacement?
With evidence from an inspection: whether the surface underneath is dry, how well the existing covering is still stuck down, the state of the details, and what the roof structure can take. The decision goes into the quotation with the reasoning, so every option, recommended or ruled out, arrives with the thinking that put it there.
How much does flat roof refurbishment cost?
There is no honest single figure: the cost depends on the option, the size, the access and what the inspection uncovers. The logic is consistent though: repairs cost least, overlays avoid the cost of stripping and disposal, and replacement costs most but resets the roof completely. You get each viable option priced in writing.
Review
What a client said
“
Very professional. Highly recommend. We'll be using services again in the future.
Leo · Google review
Not sure which option your roof needs?
That is exactly what an inspection answers. Tell us about the roof and we will take it from there.
We need a little more before we can send that: a name, the postcode of the
roof, what is happening with it, and either a phone number or an email
address.
Please check the postcode of the roof: it should have letters and numbers
in it.
Please take the link out of your message - photos can be attached with
this form.
Sorry, that did not send. What you wrote is still here, so press send
again when you have a signal. If it will not go, ring 07593 196505 or email office@pluvian.uk.
That has come through a few times already. If the first one did not
arrive, ring us instead or email
office@pluvian.uk and we will pick
it up from there.
Coming out and pricing the work is free, and every quotation for an existing roof comes with photographs of it. A written condition survey carries a fee, agreed before the visit and taken off the price of the work if you go ahead.